This would be a nice gift for any gardner, pro or novice. This came beautifully packaged inside an artistic gift box.Wooden handled Tools are medium/light weight and come with a deceptive blue plastic protection which peels off to reveal shiny silver colored metal. Nice light wood handles with leather loops for hanging on hooks.Decent quality sprayer and nice feeling sharp sheers (flower harvesting and light pruning only). The gloves are rubberized over the entire palm and across the knuckles, nice touch for staying dry and protection.Bag seems well made, no loose threads, however, the rivets and elastic ties around the opening are decorative, as there is no mechanism to cinch it tighter...Possibly could be used to attach clips?... 8 outside pockets and spacious interior allow for plenty of supplies/seeds/ties etc. Sides of bag would not stand errect with all pockets holding heavy tools...and minus any contents in main section, (but that would be unusual for most gardners...) Bird and branch design is clean and simple but the birds are missing their pupils lol! (Easily fixed with a sharpie).The only issue I find upon first inspection, (having not used the tools yet), is the edges of the shovels and W shaped tool could be smoother...Again, easy sandpaper fix but that alone looses one star for me. There is also no enclosed product information. ...Im very pleased with this useful assortment of tools and bag. Hoping this will keep me organized in the garden and keep me from loosing things. Also excited to try the weed tool!